Beyond the Throne: Comparing Characters from Macbeth and 12th Fail

 Beyond the Throne: Comparing Characters from Macbeth and 12th Fail



 I will not discuss the plot of these stories. But I wanna share my viewpoint why I like the Macbeth character more than the 12th Fail movie.


First, Macbeth was the thane of Cowdor. But; can you believe that; he pursued his goals to be a king which happened true. But, it is also right; Lady Macbeth fired his spirit to do this. Explanners thinkers think that Lady Macbeth was the villain; but what did she do? Yes; you  can say she killed the Macbeth, but how; yes, some people said that he did not choose the best option to be the king. Macbeth was a soldier or warrior. So he has the right to kill people. He opposed against the Duncan choice; he named his son as the king of the country, but Macbeth can not support it. Because, if your family, any woman can come intrusional; then what would be your feeling as a wife? Of course, you can not give over your right to control the house? It happens like that. If you think positively as a revolution of injustice; then it would be ok; or if you think as a supporter of oppression; then you would be ok. Both sides are ok. But; I would choose first one. 

Lady Macbeth just inspired him and told him to choose the option to be a king. She just inspired her and made a plot of it. At last they will succeed. But what's the problem? Yes, you may say; why would he be defeated after being a king? Yes. It was his bad luck. Because other Thanes of the state did not support him. And Macbeth does not have a good understanding of foreign relationships. Strategically, he was wrong on this side. Otherwise, I take him as a great warrior.

But ,why do I prefer Lady Macbeth over Shraddha? Lady Macbeth killed her husband to make him  king. aAnd it was a daring task and she handled the upcoming situation. But in 12th fail movie, There was no major contribution in Manoj study by Sharddha. She says - I would be your wife; be you a BCS cadre or be farmar. But he did not pass with any type of troubled days that Manoj passed. Sharddha brought up a middle class family and then became a Collector official. So, it does not signify any sign or possibilities; if Manjo would not get a chance as an IPS officer; then she would spend her life in summer scorching day in a hut; or cultivate crops on the desert land. It would not be possible for that type of hardship by an educated girl. So, it is just a myth.



No comments:

Post a Comment